COVID-19 CHHS Webinar Series: Weighing the Decision to Safely ‘Reopen’ Northern Virginia
June 16, 2020 / by Nicole Cummings
Mason Faculty and Local Partner Discuss Working Together to “Reopen” Northern Virginia While Continuing to Flatten the Curve
On May 28, 2020, the day before Northern Virginia was set to begin Phase 1 of “re-opening” aspects of the economy, the College of Health and Human Services held their second webinar in the College’s COVID-19 Webinar Series featuring a panel of to explore the issue from multiple perspectives, including economic and public health. Each distinguished guest shared their unique expertise and insight on weighing the decision to safely re-open Northern Virginia, including addressing factors that Mason will be considering when making a decision regarding the University’s plans for the fall.
Panel participants included Dr. Amira Roess, professor of global health and epidemiology; Dr. Emanuel (Chip) Petricoin, university professor and co-director at the Center for Applied Proteomics and Molecular Medicine; Sean O’Connor, professor of law at the Antonin Scalia Law School, and executive director at the Center for the Protection of Intellectual Property; Dr. Dan Houser, chair of the Department of Economics, and Victor Hoskins, president and CEO of Fairfax Economic Development. The webinar was moderated by Dean Germaine Louis.
Since May 20, states across the country have begun to expand the number of businesses and services that are open, moving away from stay-at-home-orders and into “Phase 1.”
Local commerce leaders (like Victor Hoskins), policymakers and government officials face complicated choices as they struggle to combat long-term economic repercussions, high unemployment and the possible unintended consequences of reopening prematurely.
The panel examined key indicators that decision-makers look to as signs we are ready to re-open. Roess recommended monitoring metrics such as the number of hospitalizations and fatality rates as a primary way to discern readiness, since the original objective of the stay-at-home order was to avoid overwhelming hospitals. In addition, making sure we have enough resources in place such as accessible testing, increased contact tracers, and an effective Virginia public health response system are all signs of readiness to move forward in the phases of reopening.
Furthermore, stabilizing the number of tests administered to 10,000 tests a day is critical in order to more accurately determine if there are any spikes in cases within the Northern Virginia area.
“We are missing a significant portion of [cases] through false test results. It’s not just about testing more, but testing more accurately and consistently,” emphasizes Petricoin.
During the stay-at-home-orders, many people have also been afraid to seek the help they need in order to avoid frequent doctor visits and travel. “Women with metastatic breast cancer may not be starting their trials of treatment, and patients with blood in their stools are not getting colonoscopies that may arise to stage four colon cancer the following year. We can’t be so scared of COVID that we put off the other big things that could harm us as well,” states Petricoin.
While reopening too soon could cause another wave of the virus, O’Connor expressed that extending the quarantine in the future could also cause issues in food supply and other essential industries people rely on every day to function.
“Regions need to become self-sufficient. There is no magical reopening date,” states O’Connor. Ramifications of COVID-19 affect each community and each industry differently. There is no one solution that will fit all, everyone will have to work together.
Hoskins and Houser discussed economic concern in the disproportionate impact on low income workers. People who work in retail and restaurant industries are directly affected by the pandemic and often already have lower incomes. Reopening these industries is important to do at this time, but it must be done cautiously since Phase 1 does not mean everything is back to normal. In order to succeed economically and socially, “as a community, we must accept the new social norms that will come out of this pandemic,” advises Houser.
“Any long-term solution must take into account people of all socioeconomic statuses. Long term planning is going to have to be much more inclusive if we want to reduce these massive disparities in infection and mortality rates. We need to work together to do this right the first time,” concludes Roess.
From the economical perspective, Hoskins believes now is the right time to re-open the economy. “While we should not face the world with fear, we need to defeat these new challenges with precaution. Re-opening should be done sector by sector. There may be different timing for different industries depending on what they provide,” explains Hoskins.
Some health officials fear people will re-enter too quickly into Phase 1 and may neglect safe practices in hope of returning to an immediate normal. If we are to successfully go through the motions of each phase, we will not see a full recovery of the past. Instead we must integrate new behavioral and social norms into our lives.
There are many questions that have yet to be answered regarding COVID-19, which is why many experts urge we err on the side of caution. While test accuracy is getting better, it is not quite there yet. Scientists are still unsure of how long immunity would last in a person who has been previously infected, and they are not confident immunity will last for over a year. Antibody tests (tests for past infections) may not be entirely reliable either.
“Going forward, testing accurately for asymptomatic transmission will be key,” says Roess, who is working closely with several organizations on their approach to reopening.
An audience question asked if the panel was making the decisions regarding the University’s plan for the fall 2020 semester. While the decision will ultimately be made by the Board of visitors, several of the panel members did participate in committees to inform the BOV decision. One such committee was dubbed the “tiger team.” A report presented by the “tiger team” can be viewed here.
In conclusion, even in a post-vaccine world, experts stressed that this disease will be a part of our lives, like other diseases in our lifetime such as the flu and the measles. Instead of fearing what the future holds we will adjust our behavior like we have done during any other difficult time in history.